It was a refreshing contrast to the bitter and verbal jabbing debates when McCain and Obama attended the Annual Al Smith Dinner at the Waldorf=Astoria last week. There are many kinds of comedy out there. Satire and political satire use ironic comedy to portray persons as either ridiculously silly or corrupt, thus alienating their audience from the object of humor. Satire is a type of comedy.
Screwball comedy derives its humor largely from bizarre, surprisingly impossible situations or characters. Black comedy is defined by dark humor that makes light of so called "dark" or evil elements in human nature.
At the Al Smith Dinner both McCain and Obama showed their lighter sides poking fun of themselves and each other in a playful, yet hilariously delightful way.
I loved it when McCain said that he knows Obama so well from serving with him in the Senate that he can call him "that one" without Obama taking offense. When Obama spoke, he said his name Barack means "That One" in Swahili.
I also thought that Obama saying that one of his faults is that he's almost "too awesome" and that he regrets his celebrity status as he "wanted to punch a paparazzi outside of Spago's the other night and almost spilled his latte on his Shih Tzu" as an effete almost gay retort.
On the other hand, McCain wasw too funny claiming that he still thinks there were some Manhattan Democrats out there in the audience rooting for him, then looked at Hillary and thanked her for being there.
Barack poking fun at Giuliani was priceless - and his remark that he would never wear lipstick himself - nor put it on a pig or a pit bull -- was another classic.
When McCain said he was going to fire his entire campaign staff and hire "Joe the Plumber," he was picking up on criticism of the campaign in that day's news headlines, and his material was amazingly fresh and timely.
When Barack said he was born on Krypton and his father was Jor-El and his mission was to save the earth, he also underscored the depth of his popularity and the hopes people are placing on him to "save the world."
I also loved Barack's comment that his father never thought he would ever run for President or he wouldn't have given him his middle name: (Hussein.)
All in all, when the candidates make fun of themselves and each other, it shows their talents when they are not fighting each other and the true personalities of the individuals are revealed. I found McCain much more likeable because he seemed so relaxed as a comic - then again, he is Irish!
I also felt that Barack's delivery was a little stilted compared to McCain's but that he came across as charming and witty. (More like a latte-drinking comic like Jon Stewart that Bill Maher.)
The debates were more difficult to grade because both candidates made errors: i.e., Obama when he talked about Colombia and rising labor leader murders - wrong! And McCain when he brought up Ayers - again - another negative attack without merit since Obama was a child when Ayers did his "terrorist" deeds.
If we were to judge the candidates by their sense of humor, their candidness and their personalities alone, it would be a tighter race in my mind. Since we still have to decide based on issues, the decision as to who would be a better president, still remains a difficult one for many people.
We have to think about the economy and who would help us more in terms of creating new jobs, reducing our dependency on foreign oil and energy, and how to restore confidence to boost spending.
We have to measure how much money we would save if we withdrew from Iraq and stopped playing "police" of the world.
We also have to improve education and healthcare for millions of Americans.
We also have to weigh who takes global warming and climate change more seriously.
Both of these candidates have qualities we can admire. On November 4th, we have to decide who would best serve America at this crucial time in history.